The Humane Society of the United States is very good at making the public believe they are about fluffy things like supporting local shelters and keeping animals off of the streets. In reality, HSUS and your local Humane Society shelter actually share very little in common. HSUS is actually very similar to PETA. They are both animal rights groups.
Now Humanewatch.org comes off a little strong for my taste. But they do have a very valid point: The HSUS is really not about animal shelters. It is about animal rights. And as we all know, while animal-rights organizations like PETA and HSUS can have good intentions, some of the things they support are a little crazy.
Take, for instance, the HSUS view on keeping reptiles. They have been trying to ban reptiles as pets for a very long time. Here is a link talking about how they want the White House to ban the keeping of constrictors. Ironically, no reptiles were involved in the Zaneville incident. But why do they bring it up? It is the same reason why they fail to bring up that more dogs kill people in this country than captive snakes. Politics, my friends. HSUS is an activist organization. They use rhetoric just like any politician or political group. Just like PETA. Remember that the next time you see one of those "for 50 cents a day, you can save an animal" commercials.
For reptile lovers, HSUS is not your friend. Here is an article from HSUS talking about the dangers of owning reptiles. One of the HSUS favorite tactic is trying to scare us by saying that reptiles are a huge salmonella risk. I have owned reptiles for a while. Guess what I have never caught from them? Salmonella. Guess what animals have made me sick? Mice, cats, and dogs. The fact is, you are way more likely to catch something from a mammal than from a reptile (we are mammals, after all). But the HSUS doesn't tell you that.
Don't get me wrong. The HSUS has some good beliefs. They are against animal abuse. A good portion of their funds go towards lobbying for animal rights laws. Sometimes that can be a very good thing. But not always. Next time you think HSUS, remember PETA. They are much closer than you think.
The humane society and peta are animal rights groups, not welfare. They could care less about what happens to the animals once they're out of a bad situation. The humane society is also like Peta in that they have an extremely high kill rate. I recently stopped volunteering at my local humane society after finding out about their 70% kill rate. Peta has never been under 90% in the last decade and The humane society is just as bad. They actually go against the idea of No Kill shelters, but then conveniently plays it off when a shelter successfully goes No Kill, claiming the fame and glory. The president of the HSUS actually said they'd rather kill every animal that comes into a shelter because they say the public cannot be trusted whatsoever. So euthanasia is a better solution than finding an animal a home. What kind of serial killer mentality is that? Plus I don't trust anyone who appoints the sociopathic dogkiller Michael Vick as the spokesperson of the HSUS. Media attention or not, what a huge contradiction >.<
ReplyDeleteThe HSUS states every misconception ever about reptiles as pets. Just because some people are irresponsible and uneducated reptile owners, doesn't mean everyone is. It's the same with the "public cannot be trusted" crap.
Sorry for my own little rant xD
Woohoo! You go girl :)
ReplyDeleteDifferent Humane Society shelters have different "kill rates" though. They aren't that connected. Some are no-kill, some are not. I personally don't agree with the no-kill mentality for a number of reasons (I also don't agree with "high-kill" shelters). I worked at a low-kill small animal shelter. We only put down sick, "unadoptable", or aggressive animals (and we didn't automatically assume pits were "aggressive"). Unfortunately, one of the dirty parts of being a typical animal shelter is that some animals get put down. But HSUS and your local humane society don't have a lot in common.
The HSUS view on reptile keeping is ridiculous. Like you said, just because some people are stupid doesn't mean everyone is.